Not yet a member?Join now!|Lost password
06/28/2012 | Press release
distributed by noodls on 06/28/2012 21:10
AEI health care policy experts available to comment on SCOTUS Affordable Care Act decision - with topics and contact info
IS THE AFFORDABLE CARE ACT CONSTITUTIONAL?
WILL THE SUPREME COURT STRIKE ALL OR PART OF IT DOWN?
WHAT REFORMS MIGHT REPLACE IT?
AT THE END OF THIS ADVISORY, PLEASE FIND A LIST OF
AEI SCHOLARS WHO CAN EXPLAIN THE IMPACT OF THE COURT'S
RULING - AND WHAT MIGHT COME NEXT
OUTCOME ONE:
SCOTUS does not decide if ACA is constitutional because of the Anti-Injunction Act -- an 1867 federal law which states that if you think the government has improperly imposed a tax on you, you must first pay it, request a refund, and only later file a lawsuit to challenge the tax. In this case, only after the individual mandate is enforced.
OUTCOME TWO:
The Anti-Injunction Act does not apply and:
A. Individual Mandate is found
constitutional
B. Individual Mandate is found
unconstitutional
OUTCOME THREE:
If the Individual Mandate is found unconstitutional: what
else is thrown out by SCOTUS?
A. Nothing
B. Everything
C. Specific parts (for example, only the
guaranteed issue and community rating rules for private
insurance, all of title I - private health insurance
coverage, or title I and all of title II - Medicaid
coverage and related provisions)
OUTCOME FOUR:
On a parallel track the Court could declare the Medicaid
expansion part as being too coercive and therefore
unconstitutional.
The following AEI health care scholars are available to
comment the ACA; the ruling's impact; what's next for
Medicare and Medicaid; and health reform alternatives.
Joseph
Antos
AEI Wilson H. Taylor Scholar in Health Care and Retirement
Policy
A former Assistant Director for Health and Human Resources
at the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), Antos is
currently a commissioner of the Maryland Health Services
Cost Review Commission and a health adviser to CBO.
Research areas: Impact on Medicare (and Medicare expansion); economics of health policy; health insurance.
Contact: jantos@aei.org or 202.862.5938. Research assistant catherine.griffin@aei.org (202.862.5920)
James C.
Capretta
AEI Visiting Scholar
As a former Associate Director of the White House's Office
of Management and Budget, Capretta was responsible for
health care, Social Security, and welfare issues. Earlier,
he served as a senior health policy analyst for the Senate
Budget Committee and the House Ways and Means Committee. He
is concurrently a Fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy
Center.
Research areas: Market-based alternatives to the Affordable Care Act; private sector insurance; GOP alternatives to the ACA.
Contact: james.capretta@aei.org or through research assistant catherine.griffin@aei.org (202.862.5920)
Scott
Gottlieb, M.D.
AEI Resident Fellow
A practicing physician, Dr. Gottlieb has served as a Senior
Policy Adviser at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
Services (CMS) and as a Deputy Commissioner for Medical and
Scientific Affairs at the Food and Drug Administration
(FDA)
Research areas: Impact of Affordable Care Act on physicians; impact on CMS: Medicare and Medicaid; trends in medicine (political and clinical); FDA policies.
Contact: scott.gottlieb@aei.org or through research assistant catherine.griffin@aei.org (202.862.5920)
Robert
B. Helms
AEI Resident Scholar
An economist by training, Helms was a member of the
Medicaid Commission. He has also served as an Assistant
Secretary for Planning and Evaluation and Deputy Assistant
Secretary for Health Policy at the Department of Health and
Human Services (HHS).
Research areas: Impact on Medicaid and Medicare; health economics.
Contact: rhelms@aei.org
J.D.
Kleinke
AEI Resident Fellow
An expert on health care business strategy and
entrepreneurship, Kleinke studies the interplay between
health policy, health care market dynamics and health
venture formation. He also writes about the influence of
information technology and medical technology on the
overall health economy, and the impact of medical culture
on health care organizations, markets and public health.
Research areas: Reaction of business and healthcare industry to SCOTUS decision; link between health care market dynamics and health care policy; medical technology; electronic medical records; and the overall health economy.
Contact: jd.kleinke@aei.org or through research assistant catherine.griffin@aei.org (202-862-5920)
Thomas (Tom)
P. Miller
AEI Resident Fellow
Miller can discuss the legal aspects of the case as well as
the various policy options.
A former trial attorney and former senior health economist for the Joint Economic Committee in Congress, Miller heads AEI's Beyond Repeal and Replace health policy reform project. He is the co-author of Why ObamaCare is Wrong for America (2011).
Miller is instrumental in the filing of an amicus brief on "severability" issues which makes the case for SCOTUS to invalidate only the Individual Mandate and the private insurance part of the Affordable Care Act (title I).
Research areas: Affordable Care Act and the SCOTUS decision; market-based alternatives to the Affordable Care Act; private sector health insurance.
Contact: tmiller@aei.org or 202.862.5886
More information about AEI's health care research is
available here.
Follow @AEInews on
Twitter